Olive Mill Pomace Compost as
Soil Amendment, and Sources
of Biopesticides and Animal Feed: A Review
A. Mamkagh1*, F. AL-Zyoud2 and R. Al-Atiyat3
1Dept. of Plant Production, Faculty of Agriculture,
Mutah University, Karak 61710, Jordan
2Dept. of Plant Protection and IPM, Faculty of Agriculture, Mutah University, Karak 61710,
Jordan
3Dept. of Animal Production, Faculty of Agriculture,
Mutah University, Karak 61710, Jordan
*For correspondence: amer_mam@mutah.edu.jo
Received 08 August 2022;
Accepted 22 September 2022; Published 16 October 2022
Abstract
The world's
main challenge is to increase crop productivity in a sustainable manner. Every
agricultural management decision should prioritize human health and
environmental safety. Olive mill pomace (OMP) must be disposed of practically
and affordably because it exacerbates environmental issues. If OMP is properly
handled, it has the potential to be used in agriculture for sustainable
production. Many approaches have been widely investigated in recent years as a
result of environmental protection policy to improve the recycling of OMP
through composting or use as fertilizers, biopesticides, and livestock feed.
However, there was no comprehensive work that covered the role of OMP in improving
soil properties, as well as sources of biopesticides and animal feed. The
potential use of OMP as a fertilizer, biopesticide, and animal feed was
discussed in this review. As a result, it was found that OMP can be utilized as
a high-quality soil fertilizer. It may also be a viable alternative to
synthetic pesticides for pest control, as it demonstrated a higher growth rate
of beneficial insects. Furthermore, when using OMP as feed for animals showed a
potential for tasty meats and healthy milk for ruminants and poultry without affecting
their performance and viability. The most significant result of this review
paper is that it contributes to the body of knowledge regarding the use of OMP
as a sustainable and environmentally friendly product in the production of
natural fertilizers, biopesticides, and animal feed. © 2022
Friends Science Publishers
Keywords: Waste management; Disposal; Fertilizer; Soil
infiltration; Biopesticides; Plant protection; Animal feed
Introduction
The world's
main challenge is to increase crop production in a sustainable manner. Invasive
pest pressures, pesticide misuse, global warming, water scarcity, land
degradation, and biodiversity loss all have serious consequences for worlds
food security (Al-Zyoud 2014c; Deshmukh et al. 2021). The above-mentioned
factors have already reduced the global food supply and caused a sharp decline
in global production, making it difficult to meet the food needs of billions of
people. To share improved production practices and technologies with farmers,
new technologies must be developed along with education and extension services.
In regions with low yields, new production systems must be developed and
adapted for long-term productivity under specific ecological conditions
(Al-Zyoud 2014a, b).
Olive cultivation for oil production is one of
humanity's oldest agricultural practices (Sciubba et al. 2020). Olive
oil is a key component of the Mediterranean diet because of its high
nutritional value and health benefits. Olive oil consumption has gradually
increased globally in recent decades due to increased awareness of its health
benefits, gastronomic properties, and population growth (Ortega 2006), and thus
olive growing area is expanding on an annual basis (Mili 2006). Olive oil has
superior nutritional, sensorial, and functional properties (Baccouri et al.
2008). Furthermore, due to its high oleic acid content and the presence of
antioxidants, olive oil has many beneficial effects, such as preventing certain
diseases and improving overall human health (Shdiefat et al. 2009). There are over
800 million olive trees in the world, covering a total area of 10 million
hectares (Abu-Rumman 2016). Olives are
used either as pickled olives or to produce olive oil. The global production of
table olives is estimated at 2.9 million tons, while olive oil production
exceeds 3.3 million tons. It is worth noting that the Mediterranean region
produces 97% of the world's olive oil (IOOC 2021).
Three processes are used to extract oil: the traditional
process (press process), the two-phase process, and the three-phase process
(Azbar et al. 2004). The extraction of olive oil generates a large
amount of byproducts, including olive mill wastewater (OMW) and olive mill
pomace (OMP). These two byproducts pollute the environment significantly due to
their unpleasant odor and color, acidic pH, high organic load, salinity, and
phenolic compounds (Mekersi et al. 2021). The most common extraction
process produces three phases: an oily phase (oil, 20%), a solid residue (OMP,
30%), and an aqueous phase (OMW, 50%) (Jerman and Vodopivec 2012; Omer and
Mohamed 2012). Between November and February, the Mediterranean countries
produce a large amount of OMP (Mechri et al. 2008). One of the benefits
of the 2-phase mill production system is that it uses less water and reduces
waste production by 75% (Roig et al. 2006). Depending on the extraction
system used, an estimated average volume of OMW of 0.3‒1.2 m3/ton
and quantity of OMP of 500‒735 kg/ton of processed olive have been reported
(Barbera et al. 2013; Khdair and Abu-Rumman 2020).
The OMP is a
solid by-product of olive oil production that contains water, stone skin, olive
pulp, and pit fragments, with a dry weight concentration of up to 94%
(Abu-Rumman 2016; Al-Ananzeh et al. 2016). Because the
OMP is phytotoxic and contains phenolic compounds, lipids, and organic acids,
it exacerbates environmental problems; therefore, it must be disposed of
practically and feasibly. If OMP is properly treated, it can be used in
agriculture as an ecofriendly, high-quality compost because it contains a high
organic matter content and a wide range of plant nutrients that can be reused
as fertilizers for sustainable agricultural production (Chowdhury et al.
2013). Selim et al. (2020) used bioactive compounds derived from OMP to
improve the quality of toast bread, and their findings are summarized in Table
1.
Spreading solid waste on farmlands pollutes both the
soil and the air, and the waste leaves cluttered environmental footprints (Omer
and Mohamed 2012; Dermeche et al. 2013; Galanakis 2017). Because of the
deterioration of freshwater and scarcity of agricultural water resources
(Mamkagh 2009; Mamkagh and Anderson 2018; Al-Dabbas et al. 2021), proper
disposal of OMP is critical to reduce its negative effects on groundwater
(Tawarah and Rababah 2013). Other reported potential uses of OMP include
fertilizers (Haddadin et al. 2009), an effective alternative to
synthetic pesticides (Cayuela et al. 2008), animal fodders (Haddadin and
Abdulrahim 1999), and a source for the manufacture of activated carbon (Mameri et
al. 2000). Many approaches have been widely investigated to improve the
recycling of OMP through composting (Parascanu et al. 2018), or to use
it as construction materials, livestock feed, biofuel, and thermal insulation
(Chouchene et al. 2010), pharmaceutical, food, chemicals
(biopesticides), and energy (Asveld et al. 2011) (Fig. 1).
This
strategy's OMP is used in three sectors: food and feed, industrial products,
and bioenergy. Thus, the higher value in the Pyramid represents food and feed,
which would be used first before reaching utilization for energy generation.
Surprisingly, the majority of countries, including those in the Middle East,
use and apply OMP for bioenergy and biofuels, which are at the bottom of the
value pyramid.
Due to the fact that raw OMP includes significant
quantities of phytotoxic chemicals that might harm both the soils and the
plants, it cannot be added to the soils without prior treatment (Pages et
al. 1982). However, when OMP is used as a soil amendment after composting,
it can significantly reduce phytotoxicity, and may benefit soil and plant
growth and development (Komilis and Tziouvaras 2009). Similarly, when OMP was
used as a livestock feedstuff, it showed promising results in terms of lowering
feed costs in countries with limited feed supply and high feed prices
(Al-Atiyat 2014), as well as improving meat and dairy product quality (Berbel
and Posadillo 2018). Nevertheless, for the aforementioned considerations, we
conducted a systematic literature search for relevant works on OMP. However,
there has been no comprehensive study of the role and value of OMP biomass in
improving soil properties, and as sources of biopesticides and animal feed.
Thus, in this review we focused on soil properties, fertilizers, infiltration,
OMP as biopesticides and their role in plant protection, human and
environmental safety, soil-borne plant pathogens, and their value in animal
feed. The most important result of this review paper is that
it adds to the global pool of knowledge about OMP and fills a gap in the
literature about the use of OMP as an environmentally friendly pest control
tactic, a source of animal feed, and potential effects on soil when used as
natural fertilizers.
Methodology
Herein, we
conducted a systematic search of literature for relevant works on OMP. The OMP
data were obtained from the websites of Web of Science, Google Scholar, Scopus
(Elsevier), and ResearchGate. The following keywords were used in our search:
olive, Olea europaea, olive by-products, olive mill pomace, olive-mill
solid waste compost, solid residue phase, organic composts, compost amendments,
soil properties, fertilizer compost, infiltration, water holding capacity, and
nutrients. Furthermore, the following keywords were used in the field of plant
protection: integrated pest management (IPM), sustainability, biopesticides,
plant protection, human and environmental safety, alternative pest control
methods, ecofriendly sound pest control tactic, cost-effective control,
soil-borne plant pathogens, air-borne plant pests, plant diseases, nematodes,
and soil microorganisms. Furthermore, the following terms were used in the
field of animal production: animal feed, livestock husbandry, poultry, meat and
milk quality, small ruminants, metabolic energy, and animal performance.
Compost
preparation and soil physical properties
Compost
preparation: To make the compost, OMP was mixed in a 1:2 ratio with
olive leaves. The mixture was then placed in a covered rectangular windrow for
60 days, and turned weekly. Tap water was added as needed to keep the moisture
level around 50%. Following that, the compost was removed from the windrow to
mature before being piled in a covered area for other 60 days. Several samples,
each weighing 10 g, were taken from the compost during the trail to assess
phytotoxicity using the germination index. Finally, the compost made from OMP
and leaves contains enough nutrients to be a high-quality soil amendment, and
it is better suited for small olive mill plants due to the short composting
period (Michailides et al. 2011).
Compost and
soil chemical and physical properties
Several
studies found that using OMP compost improved soil chemical and physical
properties because an increase in nutrients, particularly nitrogen, potassium, and
phosphorous, is required by plants (Sellami et al. 2008; Buono et al.
2011). Composting is a natural bio-chemical aerobic process of organic waste
materials, such as agricultural wastes, that can enrich the soil and plants by
providing an ideal environment for decomposing organisms. Composting consists
of three stages: initial activation, thermophilic, and mesophilic decomposition
(Ryckeboer et al. 2003). Microorganisms produce water, minerals, carbon
dioxide, and stabilized organic matter (Giusquiani et al. 1995), so that
caution is required because the absence of environmental control during the
process will result in natural degradation and rotten.
Nonetheless, the most important components of compost,
such as phosphorous, nitrogen, organic matter, and trace elements, have a
positive effect on soil fertility and structure, thus increasing agricultural
productivity (Senesi 1989). Compost, as an alternative fertilizer, improves
soil infiltration and water holding capacity by increasing microbial activity
compounds, improving aggregate stability and cation exchange, and increasing
aggregate stability (Cooperband 2002). OMP must be composted for at least 18
weeks to eliminate any phytotoxic effect and make it easier to manage (Cayuela et
al. 2007). Composting can sanitize and stabilize OMP, as well as reduce its
mass and volume before mixing it with soil. Composted OMP has the same amount
of organic matter as horse, pig, and rabbit manures and more than cow, sheep,
and poultry manures. It is preferable to compost OMP with natural organic
residues such as manures, straws, olive twigs, and leaves, allowing them to
decompose in aerated piles for 7‒9 months
(Gomez-Munoz et al. 2012).
OMP addition
effect on soil properties
Bueno et
al. (2014) investigated the effect of compost made from OMP on the physical
and chemical properties of sandy loam soil with low organic matter levels and
no salinity issues. The compost was made by combining OMP with olive leaves and
horse manure. The following are some of the main chemical properties of the
tested compost: 9.46 pH, 67.00 organic matter, 1030 mS/cm electrical
conductivity, 1.85 g/kg nitrogen, 0.36 g/kg phosphorus, and 2.00 g/kg
potassium. The addition of OMP compost significantly reduced hydraulic
conductivity, while increasing organic matter in the soil. Furthermore, it was
reported that the electrical conductivity of the soil increased immediately
after the application of compost, but rapidly decreased with the passage of
time. The authors attributed this discovery to the ease with which the high
initial salt contents were washed away by consecutive irrigation. Moreover,
Abu-Rumman (2016) investigated the effect of varying proportions of fresh OMP
on the bulk density, accumulated intake, and water holding capacity of clay and
sandy clay soils. Table 2 displays the physicochemical properties of the tested
OMP samples. When, OMP was added to the soil at the start of the experiment,
there were no changes in soil infiltration. This finding was attributed to a
decrease in water advance and penetration caused by an increase in soil water
holding capacity. The same study demonstrated that soil with OMP compost takes
less time to reach its maximum water holding capacity. During the experiment,
there was also an increase in cumulative water intake in the sandy soil
initially, followed by the clay soil. As a result of the positive effects on
soil physical properties, it is recommended to use OMP as a soil amendment. It
should be noted that untreated OMP from a three-phase olive mill was used as a
soil amendment without considering the potential negative effects on the soil
and the environment (Abu-Rumman 2016).
In 2019, Diacono and Montemurro studied the effects of
OMP compost on soil characteristics and heavy metals in both plants and soil.
Fresh OMP was obtained from a two-phase olive oil mill. Eighty-two kg of OMP
were combined with 10 kg of poultry manure and 8 kg of wheat straw to make the
compost. Following that, the mixture was continuously stirred in an open field
to ensure oxidation and homogeneity. The temperature of the mixture ranged
between 50°C and 60°C during the thermophilic phase of composting (40 days),
and between 35°C and 45°C during the mesophilic phase (150 days), while the
moisture ranged between 50 and 60% almost throughout the preparation time.
Table 2 shows the main chemical properties of the compost obtained during the
experiment. However, no significant accumulation of heavy metals in the soil
was observed, so the authors proposed recycling olive mill wastes in an
environmentally friendly manner by using the OMP compost to produce a useful
nitrogen source in organic farming and to reduce the input of mineral
fertilizers in conventional agriculture productions (Diacono and Montemurro
2019).
The role of olive mill pomace in plant protection
Pesticides: Pesticides have aided humans in meeting rising food
demand by increasing agricultural output through pest control. Chemical control
has been the most commonly used control tactic in recent decades, ensuring high
yields for farmers (Al-Zyoud 2014c). After more than 70 years of pesticides
usage worldwide, their side effects on aquatic and terrestrial ecosystems are
obvious (Oguh et al. 2019a; Siddique et al. 2020). Intensive use
of pesticides has resulted in increased pest resistance (Muraro et al.
2021), and negative environmental and human health impacts (Ghabeish et al.
2021). Exposure to pesticides is increasingly linked to human health
implications, i.e., immune
suppression, reproductive abnormalities, nervous system disorders (Campagna et
al. 2009), cancer (Amanullah and Hari 2011), asthma and diabetes (Jayashree
and Singhi 2011), Alzheimers dementia, Parkinsons diseases, allergies (Hong et
al. 2014), and death (Raipulis et al. 2009). It is reported that
pesticides contaminate rivers, groundwater (Pattnaik et al. 2020), soil
and air (Oguh et al. 2019a). According to an estimate, water bodies within
40% of the global land surface are at risk of pesticide pollution (Ippolito et
al. 2015). High doses and frequent pesticide applications have adversely
affected natural enemies (Al-Zyoud 2014c, 2015), birds (Mitra et al.
2011), fish and wildlife (Pattnaik et al. 2020), beneficial soil
microorganisms, plant yields (Glover-Amengor and Tetteh 2008), and caused crop
phytotoxicity (Burger et al. 2008). Pesticide misuse can also cause
undesirable residue accumulation in food crops (Andrade et al. 2015).
Pesticide residues absorb by plants, enter the food chain and accumulate in
human and animal body fats (Pattnaik et al. 2020), and may cause serious
problems in dairy animals (Choudhary et al. 2018). The persistence
nature of some pesticides led to their accumulation in animal tissues, organs,
muscles and blood, and subsequently causes human dietary exposure to these
pesticides through consumption of animal products (Pattnaik et al.
2020). Normally pesticides enter into the animal body through contaminated
feed, water and through passive diffusion when used as ectoparasiticides (Singh
et al. 2014). Presence of pesticide residues in tissues and organs of
goats, cattle, sheep, lambs and chicken have been reported worldwide (Singh et
al. 2014). An estimate shows death and chronic diseases due to pesticide
poisoning about 1 million cases/year worldwide (Pattnaik et al. 2020).
However, due to pesticide residues and resistance issues, it has recently
become clear that more ecofriendly sound control tactics are urgently needed
for agricultural policymakers (Al-Zyoud et al. 2021; Lin et al.
2021).
Pest management
Pest management is a mean of reducing pest population to
an acceptable or economical threshold (Oguh et al. 2019b). Studies
indicate increased pest resistance to pesticides (Naharki et al. 2020), and pesticides becomes ineffective (Mariyono 2008), as
well as the complete dependency on pesticides caused adverse effects to
environment, human and livestock (Samiee et
al. 2009).
Thus, every pest management decision should prioritize human health and
environmental safety (Al-Zyoud 2014a, b). However, sustainable agriculture is a
key element of sustainable development and essential to the future of human
being (Shojaei et al. 2013). Sustainability aims to achieve adequate
safe and healthy food production, and improve livelihoods of food producers
(Uwagboe et al. 2012). Integrated pest management (IPM) is used to
manage pest damage by the most economical means and the least hazards to human
and environment (Ofuoku et al. 2009). IPM is a decision-based process
involving coordinated use of multiple tactics for optimizing pest control in an
ecologically and economically sound manner (Al-Zyoud 2014a, b). IPM tactics are
designed to provide economic benefits, reduce environment and human health
risks, and solve the problem of pest resistance to pesticides (Al-Zyoud et
al. 2015; Naharki et al. 2020). The world supports the use of IPM in
agriculture as the best environmentally sound approach to pest control
(Al-Zyoud et al. 2021). To mitigate the ecotoxicological, environmental,
and social consequences of synthetic pesticides, it is therefore critical to
investigate effective, economical, safe, and ecological alternative pest
control methods compatible with sustainable development (Carvalho 2017).
Use of OMP as biopesticides in crop pest management
Olive pomace as a source of biopesticides: During the past three decades, efforts have been made to
reduce the exposure and human risk of pesticides, thus, some conventional
pesticides have been replaced by newer bioiopesticides. Biopesticides are
third-generation pesticides that are environmentally friendly and closely
resemble or are identical to chemicals produced in nature (Niassy et al.
2021; Paredes-Sanchez et al. 2021). Biopesticides are effective,
biodegradable with no residuals in the environment (Tijjani et al.
2016). Biopesticides are naturally occurring substances from living organisms
(natural enemies) or their products (microbial products, phytochemicals) or
their by-products (semiochemicals) that can control pests by nontoxic
mechanisms (Salma and Jogen 2011; Bateman et al. 2021; Lin et al.
2021; Niassy et al. 2021; Paredes-Sanchez et al. 2021).
Biopesticides fall into four major categories: microbial pesticides (Chandler et
al. 2011), biochemical pesticides (Pal and Kumar 2013),
plant-incorporated-protectants (Deshmukh et al. 2021), and
semiochemicals (Al-Dosary et al. 2016). Biopesticides are pesticides
made by organisms usually for their own defense, or are derived from a natural
source such as plant, animal, bacteria, and certain minerals, use to control
pest naturally with less effect or no effect (Oguh et al. 2019a, b).
Biopesticides usually target specific sites in the insect such as nervous
system, resulting in knock-down, lack of coordination, paralysis and death
(Oguh et al. 2019b). Most botanical pesticides show their effect through
contact, respiratory, or stomach poisons to the target organism. Botanical
pesticides are generally highly bio-degradable, and they become inactive within
hours or a few days and can easily be Table 1: Composition of fresh OMP (g/100 g) (Two-phase olive oil
extraction)
Physicochemical
properties |
Value |
Moisture |
64.58 ± 2.51 |
Total
lipids |
02.33 ± 0.06 |
Protein |
02.48 ± 0.04 |
Ash |
01.13 ± 0.02 |
Carbohydrates |
29.48 ± 2.41 |
Cud fiber* |
20.37 ± 1.65 |
Cellulose* |
40.77 ± 2.44 |
Hemicelluloses* |
33.63 ± 2.28 |
Lignin* |
19.50 ± 1.79 |
*Calculated as a percentage from OMP fiber (% on a dry weight basis)
(Adopted from Selim et al. 2020)
Fig. 1:
Pyramid of biomass value (Adopted from Asveld et al. 2011)
broken down by stomach acids in
mammals, so toxicity to humans and animals is very low (Oguh et al.
2019b). The recognized categories of bio-pesticides may be synthetic or natural
compounds of microbial, plant protectant and biochemical (pheromones, hormones,
natural growth regulators and enzymes) origins (Dimetry 2012; Oguh et al.
2019b). Biopesticides are considered as eco-friendly safer for user, rapid
degradation, narrow spectrum of activity, cheaper, less toxic to workers or
consumers; safer for beneficial insects, may be used shortly before harvesting,
act very quickly inhibiting insect feeding, not phytotoxic, and resistance to
these compounds is not developed as quickly as with synthetic pesticides (Oguh et
al. 2019b), thus biopesticides should be the first choice for pest
management, which in turn reduces the bioavailability of metal and noxious
effect in the environment.
Biopesticides are the best candidates for sustainable
integrated crop productivity and pest management as an alternative to synthetic
pesticides (Drobek et al. 2019; Ogunnupebi et al. 2020). Many
researchers have been inspired to use bioactive molecules with growth promotion
and antimicrobial effects found in OMW by-products as biopesticides for crop
protection. Biopesticides have recently been identified as the best candidates
for phytopathogen control in sustainable agriculture (Sciubba et al.
2020). Organic soil amendments have the potential to be safer alternatives to
the harmful synthetic pesticides that are currently used to control plant pests
(Sasanelli et al. 2011). The OMP has antimicrobial activity and
anti-pest properties, possibly due to the presence of bioactive molecules such
as phenols and polysaccharides and is expected to drive the future development
of more sustainable agriculture (Sciubba et al. 2020). Compost made from
plant debris is viewed as a viable alternative to synthetic chemicals for
improving plant growth by improving soil physicochemical properties, nutritive
effects, and nutrient content (Scotti et al. 2016). Aside from their
high agronomic value, several studies have reported their potential use as
biopesticides and suppressive abilities against many soil- and air-borne plant
pathogens (Corato et al. 2019; Coelho et al. 2020). As a result, Table 2: Physicochemical
and chemical properties of compost made from OMP
extracted using a two-phase olive oil mill
Physicochemical
properties |
Value |
Chemical properties |
Value |
|
|||
Temperature
(°C) |
25 |
pH |
8.63 |
||||
Moisture
content (Fresh weight %) |
70 |
Zinc (Zn)
(g/kg) |
0.202 |
||||
pH |
5.40 |
Total
nitrogen (g/kg) |
23.44 |
||||
Conductivity
(dS/m) |
4.35 |
Copper (Cu)
(g/kg) |
98.81 |
||||
Total
nitrogen (g/kg) |
12.4 |
Phosphorus
(P) (g/kg) |
7.053 |
||||
Carbon/Nitrogen
(C/N) |
32.20 |
Lead (Pb)
(mg/kg) |
30.82 |
||||
Phosphorus
(P) (g/kg) |
0.90 |
Nickel (Ni)
(mg/kg) |
05.55 |
||||
Sodium (Na)
(g/kg) |
0.70 |
Total
organic carbon (TOC) (g/kg) |
245.2 |
||||
Potassium
(K) (g/kg) |
0.90 |
Dry matter (%) |
84.6 |
||||
Calcium
(Ca) (g/kg) |
2.30 |
Crude protein (%) |
9.02 |
||||
Total
organic carbon (TOC) (g/kg) |
590.0 |
Crude fat |
7.6 |
||||
Ash (g/kg) |
72.40 |
Crude fiber |
40.6 |
||||
(Adopted from
Youssef et al. 2001, Abu-Rumman
2016; Diacono and Montemurro 2019)
Fig. 2: Scheme of
extraction methods. (OMWW = olive mill wastewater)
Table 3: Effects of
olive mill pomace compost as a biopesticide against different pests and their
host plants (crops)
Pest |
Crop |
Reference |
Verticillium wilt disease (Verticillium
dahliae) |
Olive |
Varo-Suarez et al.
(2017) |
Onion white rot disease (Sclerotinia cepivorum ) |
Onion |
Martin and Ramsubhag (2015) |
Lettuce root rot disease (Sclerotinia sclerotiorum) |
Luttuce |
Martin and Ramsubhag (2015) |
Phytophthora
root rot disease (Phytophthora
nicotianae)
|
Tomato |
Ntougias
et al. (2008) |
Stem rot
disease (Sclerotium rolfsii) |
Tomato |
Ayed et al. (2022) |
Verticillium wilt disease (Verticillium
dahliae) |
Pepper |
Tubeileh
and Stephenson (2020) |
Root-knot
nematode (Meloidogyne incognita) |
Cantaloupe
|
DAddabbo
et al. (2003) |
Fruit rot
disease (Sclerotium rolfsii) |
Pumpkin |
Mahadevakumar et al. (2016) |
Rhizoctonia
damping-off disease (Rhizoctonia
solani) |
Bean |
Corato
et al. (2019) |
Verticillium wilt disease (Verticillium
dahliae) |
Eggplant |
Corato
et al. (2019) |
The mold pathogens: Aspergillus
clavatus, Aspergillus flavus, Aspergillus terreus, Aspergillus
niger |
Alfalfa |
Omer
and Mohamed (2012) |
Root-knot nematode (Meloidogyne
incognita) |
Tomato |
Kavdir
et al. (2019) |
Root-knot
nematode (Meloidogyne incognita) |
Tomato |
Radwan
et al. (2009) |
Common purslane,
redroot pigweed and jungle rice weeds |
Okra |
Boz et al.
(2009) |
Little seed
canary grass, annual bluegrass, wild chamomile, and shepherd's-purse weeds |
Faba bean and
onion |
Boz et al.
(2009) |
composting is regarded as the most effective and
environmentally safe treatment for producing an agronomically beneficial organic
amendment. This is an environmentally safe, efficient, and cost-effective
treatment for recycling biodegradable materials, typically organic mixtures,
resulting in a stabilized end product known as compost (Maniadakis et al.
2004). Compost is a renewable organic resource that can be widely used in
agriculture to control pests and improve plant health (Liguori et al.
2015; Corato et al. 2018). In fact, compost amendment improves crop
yield by suppressing soil-borne pathogens (Mahadevakumar et al. 2016). The
disease-suppressing potential of composts is governed by their microbial
consortium and the ability of their associated beneficial bacteria to compete
with the target plant pathogen.
The role of OMP in pest management
Regarding fungal pathogens that
caused huge losses to crops, it has been found that composts are capable of
suppressing soil-borne plant pathogens more efficiently than synthetic
fungicides such as tebuconazole and vinclozolin in controlling the onion white
rot induced by Sclerotinia cepivorum and the lettuce root rot caused by S.
sclerotiorum (Martin and Ramsubhag 2015). Studies showed the suppressive
capacity of organic composts against various soil-borne diseases induced by Fusarium
oxysporum, Rhizoctonia solani, Verticillium dahliae, S.
minor, S. sclerotiorum,
Phytophthora infestans and Pythium ultimum
associated with different host plants (Mahadevakumar et
al. 2016; Corato et al. 2019; Tubeileh and Stepgenson 2020). The OMP
had inhibitory effects on the plant pathogens; Aspergillus clavatus, Aspergillus
flavus, Aspergillus terreus, F. oxysporum and Verticillim
dhaliae (Alfano et al. 2011; Omer and Mohamed 2012). The higher
inhibition capability of mature compost may be explained by the formation of
toxic metabolites by some microbial communities that developed in the piles
during the composting process (Cayuela et al. 2008). In a
plate-inhibition experiment, OMP exerted a significant inhibitory effect on the
growth of F. oxysporum f. spp.
lycopersici and P. ultimum (Gabriele et al. 2011). In potted experiment to assess the effect of OMP against
soil- and air borne pathogens of tomato, it was reported that OMP has a high
level of suppressiveness against Phytophthora nicotianae in tomato (81‒100% reduction in plant disease incidence) (Ntougias
et al. 2008). Taken into account that stem rot caused by Sclerotium rolfsii
is one of the most devastating diseases in tomato (Sun
et al. 2020), a mixture includes OMP was evaluated for its
ability to control this disease and to promote tomato plant growth. The tested compost was effective in
decreasing disease severity from 31.2 to 56.2%,
and has significantly enhanced tomato-growth parameters i.e., plant height, stem diameter,
and dry weights of aerial parts and roots (Ayed et al. 2022). These
findings agreed with those of Tubeileh and Stephenson (2020) who found the highest
disease control potential of OMP against P. nicotianae and V. dahliae.
The use of organic amendments could represent one of the
possible alternatives to synthetic nematicides in the control of nematodes. An
OMP incorporated into a soil infested by the root-knot nematode, Meloidogyne
incognita was found to suppress M. incognita in tomato glasshouse
experiments. The number of eggs and juveniles of nematodes on cantaloupe roots
and in the soil were significantly reduced in the OMP treatment compared to the
untreated control (DAddabbo et al. 2003). In-vitro conditions, the
efficacy of OMP at different rates was evaluated against the 2nd
stage juveniles (J2) of M. incognita mixed with sandy loam soil at
different rates under controlled conditions on tomato, and it was found that
OMP reduced M. incognita by 53% as compared to the control. Higher rates
of OMP added into the soil resulted in healthy and much longer root systems,
and higher plant fresh and dry weights than those in the control treatment (Kavdir
et al. 2019). In addition, M. incognita populations in the soil
and root galling were significantly reduced when OMP was added to the soil, and
OMP was the most effective when applied at the highest rate (50 g/kg), since it
reduced J2 in the soil by 92%. Thus, OMP could prove to be a main component of
IPM for the root-knot nematodes in plants in organic farming (Radwan et al.
2009).
Field experiments were carried out to evaluate the weed control efficacy
of OMP in okra, faba bean, and onion. The OMP was incorporated into the soil
prior to seeding at 10, 20, 30 and 40 t/ha, and it was found that OMP control
common purslane, redroot pigweed, and junglerice weed in okra; little seed canary
grass, annual bluegrass, wild chamomile, and shepherd's-purse in faba bean and
onion. The OMP was in most cases equally as effective as soil synthetic
herbicides, and OMP had no negative effects on plants. Overall, OMP can be
applied at a rate of 10-20 t/ha for weed control with adequate crop safety (Boz
et al. 2009). Concerning beneficial insects, a study was evaluated the effect of
environmentally realistic concentrations of OMP on the growth, reproduction and
survival of the earthworms, Aporrectodea trapezoides and Eisenia
fetida. Results showed a higher growth rate of E. fetida when
exposed to 12.5% OMP (Mekersi et al. 2021). Examples of using OMP compost as a
biopesticide against some pests on crops are listed in Table 3.
The role of OMP in animal feed
The OMP is used
as an alternative to traditional feed resources in every country where the
olive oil industry exists, in addition to the other uses mentioned in the
preceding sections. Indeed, livestock husbandry in the dry areas of the
Mediterranean Basin faces scarcity and fluctuation in feed supply and feed
prices (Al-Atiyat 2014). Thus, OMP has been successfully used as a source of
animal feed in the livestock industry in the Mediterranean region. Nonetheless,
using OMP for animal feed lowers feeding costs while improves the quality of
meat and other dairy products (Berbel and Posadillo 2018). The use of OMP has
no negative effects on milk production or the fattening of small ruminants
(Tzamaloukas et al. 2021). Indeed, these authors found that OMP
increases monounsaturated fatty acid levels while decreasing saturated fatty
acid levels in both milk and meat, resulting in positive health effects for
consumers. It is worth noting that the percentage of protein in OMP containing
stones is around 5%, whereas the percentage of protein in bagasse from which
the stones were completely removed is around 12%. In both cases, OMP's protein
contains low levels of essential amino acids, which is an important factor in
determining its nutritional value, particularly when used in rations without
the use of chemicals. The percentage of fat in the OMP, on the other hand,
varies, and this is primarily determined by the method of extracting oils from
the olive during the manufacturing processes. If the oil is extracted by
pressing method, the percentage of fat ranges between 14.5 and 23%; however, if
organic solvents are used (Fig. 2), the percentage decreases. The oil content
of the resulting material is 5%. Furthermore, OMP supplementation increases the
levels of monounsaturated fatty acids (MUFAs) and decreases that of saturated
fatty acids (SFAs) in the milk and meat of ruminants with beneficial effects
for consumers health (Tzamaloukas et al. 2021). OMP contains a
significant amount of metabolic energy, but the degree to which this energy is
utilized by the animal is usually reduced due to the high percentage of crude
fiber in this substance (57%) (Al-Jassim et al. 1997). In terms of
minerals, OMP is a good source of calcium. It does, however, contain trace
amounts of phosphorous, magnesium, and sodium (see Table 2 for lists the
chemical composition of OMP).
The addition of OMP to the rations was based on successful
trials and experiments that showed a positive effect on performance and/or feed
costs. In summary, numerous efforts have been made to improve the nutritional
value of OMP in order to increase its use in animal diets, chemical and
biological treatments. Despite the fact that OMP as a feed source additive may
improve livestock production, there are a few drawbacks. The first is that OMP,
due to its relatively high water content and the still large amount of oil it
retains, becomes rancid and unfit for animal consumption when exposed to air.
Another issue is the need to remove toxins and tannins from PMO before using it
as a feed supplement. According to this review, we will only look at the
benefits of using OMP as feed for each species of livestock based on recently
published scientific articles. In fact, it has inspired a business that
collects and processes olive waste using advanced technology and converts it
into animal feed.
The OMP as a
feed in dairy cattle studies is scarce and shows different feedback with variable
results due to different methods of producing OPM (e.g., processing and pressing as wet or dehydrated or absence or
presence of stone) (Castellani et al. 2017; Vargas-Bello-Pιrez et al.
2018). In general, a supplementation level of 520% had no effect on milk
yield. The OMP diet had a significant impact on milk protein content. In
details, reasonable results were obtained when OMP was added to the total diet
at a 15‒17% level. In
comparison to the control treatment, this addition level increased the ether
extract by approximately 60‒65%. Nonetheless, it was reported that using 15% OMP in
the diet of cattle, buffaloes, goats, sheep, and camels resulted in a 65%
increase in ether extract (Fayed et al. 2001; Terramoccia et al. 2013;
Chaves et al. 2021). As a result, it is advised to feed OMP to dairy
animals when they require energy. For example, it is well understood that
energy balance in dairy cows is achieved by energy intake to meet their daily
requirements for various functions during the early lactation stage. The OMP, on
the other hand, altered the fatty acid profile of milk. When OPM was used as a
feed, Castellani et al. (2017) found an increase in conjugated linoleic
acid, a decrease in short- and medium-chain fatty acid, and no difference in
polyunsaturated fatty acid levels. In the beef industry, OMP showed promise as
a supplementary feed. In addition, OMP inclusions at 15% reduced meat cooking
loss and shear force value (Chiofalo et al. 2020), whereas OMP inclusion
at 4.8% had no effect on growth performance, carcass traits, or meat sensory
attributes (Castro et al. 2016). The OMP improved the nutritional value,
texture, tenderness, and digestibility of produced meat; particularly for
breeds such as Wagyu cattle (Japanese breed). Dunne (2019) also reported that
the high fat marbling in Wagyu meat contributes to a lower melting point.
Supplementing
OMP had a positive effect on the ratio of saturated to unsaturated fatty acids.
It was reported that OMP feed improves meat flavor and increasing tenderness as
well. Studies showed an increase of 50 and 100% in glutamic acid and carnosine,
respectively, reflecting nutritional benefits and significantly taste
corresponding to the flavour of glutamates. Such notable results were reported in
the high-end Wagyu beef cattle breed of Japan. When fed at 20% as a destoned
olive cake of the dietary ration, the OMP as feed for fattening sheep and goats
(lambs and kids) showed a significant difference in body weight, growth rate,
and feed conversion ratio (Sadeghi et al. 2009). Because it is a
low-cost byproduct, OMP can be used as an alternative feed source for lambs at
a rate of 20‒30% without
affecting their growth performance or carcass traits (Christodoulou et al.
2008; Alkhtib et al. 2021).
Finally,
due to its low protein and high fiber contents, OMP is still limited as a feed
for poultry, primarily layer and broiler chickens. In general, the findings of
various studies showed that including up to 10% OMP in the diet of broiler
chickens and commercial laying hens has no negative effects on the birds'
performance and improves meat quality (Saleh and Alzawqari 2021). Furthermore,
when up to 9% OMP is included in diets, egg weight and yolk index increase
(Oliveira et al. 2021). The OMP can also change the lipid profile of
chicken meat and egg yolk, increase the amount of monounsaturated fatty acids
while decrease the amount of saturated fatty acids. Broiler gut microbiota has
higher antibody titers for infectious bronchitis and gumboro diseases (Oliveira
et al. 2021).
Conclusions and Perspectives
It is
concluded that when composting OMP, natural organic residues such as manure,
straw, olive twigs, and leaves should be added to allow them to decompose in
aerated piles. Compost from OMP contains enough nutrients without containing
any harmful heavy metals, and it affects the hydraulic conductivity,
infiltration, and water holding capacity of the soil in various ways depending
on the soil texture and structure. As a result, we recommend using OMP as
compost while taking into account the environmental consequences on soil and
water, as it can be a high-quality soil fertilizer. Furthermore, many of the
compounds found in OMP could be a promising option for pest control in the
Mediterranean region, but more field research is needed to assess its effects
on specific pest problems in specific cropping systems. The use of OMP composts
as biodegradable pesticides may have many applications in organic agriculture.
The development of a sustainable pest control strategy based on the use of OMP
composts in order to reduce the use of synthetic pesticides may have
significant economic benefits. More research is needed in this context to
investigate the feasibility of incorporating OMP into large-scale pest
management programs. Furthermore, considering OMP as animal feed resulted in
increased revenue and the potential for tasty meat and healthy milk. Because it
is a cheap by-product, OMP can be used as an alternative feed source for
livestock up to 20% for ruminants and 10% for poultry without affecting their
performance viability. It can be concluded that it is a primary solution for
the elimination of OMP waste and the associated environmental and economic
issues. Additional research is needed to assess the long-term impact of
uncontrolled OMP disposal in agricultural land, as well as the risk of soil and
water contamination. In addition, since all the studies on OMP were conducted
on controlling diseases, nematodes and weed pests, future studies should be
done to test its efficacy against insect pests. Furthermore, future research
should be focused on how feeding livestock by op could affect animal biodiversity
and/or growth traits.
Acknowledgments
None to
declare.
Author
Contributions
All authors (Mamkagh, A.; AL-Zyoud, F. and Al-Atiyat, R.) searched in the literature, wrote, reviewed and approved the final
version of the manuscript equally.
Conflicts of Interest
The authors
declare no conflict of interest.
Funding Source
This review
paper received no external funding.
References
Abu-Rumman G
(2016). Effect of olive mill solid waste on soil physical properties. Intl J
Soil Sci 11:94101
Al-Ananzeh N,
S Shakatreh, K Al-Ajlouni, A Al-Bsoul, M Chiha (2016). Characterization and
thermal analysis of olive mills solid residues (peat, pit and pulp) in Jordan: Case
study: Irbid, Ajloun, Jarash and Jordan Valley. Ener Sour A: Rec Utiliz
Environ Effects 38:18051811
Al-Atiyat R
(2014). Role of small-scale dairy sector in food security and poverty
alleviation. J Food Agric Environ 12:427433
Al-Dabbas M, A
Alahmer, A Mamkagh, MR Gomaa (2021). Productivity enhancement of the solar
still by using water cooled finned condensing pipe. Desalin Water Treat
213:3543
Al-Dosary NM, S
Al-Dobai, JR Faleiro (2016). Review on the management of red palm weevil Rhynchophorus
ferrugineus Olivier in date palm Phoenix dactylifera L. Emir J
Food Agric 28:3444
Alfano G, G
Lustrato, G Lima, D Vitullo, G Ranalli (2011). Characterization of composted
olive mill wastes to predict potential plant disease suppressiveness. Biol
Contr 58:199207
Al-Jassim RAM, FT Awadeh, A Abodabos (1997).
Supplementary feeding value of urea-treated olive cake when fed to growing
Awasi lambs. Anim Feed Sci Technol 64:287292
Alkhtib A, M
Muna, E Burton, J Wamatu, M Darag, E Alkhaled, Z Al-Asaad, H Almoufachi, R
Zaeowd (2021). Effect of olive tree leaves and twigs on intake, digestibility,
growth performance and blood variables of Shami goats. Vet Med Sci 7:908914
Al-Zyoud F (2015). Investigating barriers to adoption of biological control
technology by vegetables and fruit trees growers in Jordan. Jor J Agric Sci 11:10831101
Al-Zyoud F (2014a). Adoption of integrated pest
management among fruit trees growers in
Jordan. Egyp J Agric Sci
65:318336
Al-Zyoud F (2014b). Adoption range of integrated pest
management techniques by greenhouse vegetable growers in Jordan. Jor J Agric
Sci 10:504525
Al-Zyoud F (2014c).
Indiscriminate
use and improper application of pesticides by Jordanian vegetable and fruit
farmers. Egypt J Agric Sci
65:344359
Al-Zyoud FA, RA Shibli, I Ghabeish (2021). Current management, challenges
and future perspectives of red palm weevil Rhynchophorus ferrugineus
Olivier (Col., Curculionidae) eradication
a review. J Exp Biol
Agric Sci 9:697714
Al-Zyoud F, D Hassawi, I Ghabeish (2015). Oxalic acid as
an alienate factor for wheat and barley resistance to cereal leaf miner Syringopais
temperatella (Lederer, 1855) (Lepidoptera: Scythrididae). SHILAP Rev
Lepidopterol 43:113123
Amanullah
M, BY Hari (2011). Evaluation of carbamate insecticides as chemotherapeutic
agents for cancer. Ind J Cancer 48:7479
Andrade
GCR, SH Monteiro, JG Francisco, LA Figueiredo, AA Rocha, VL Tornisielo (2015).
Effects of types of washing and peeling in relation to pesticide residues in
tomatoes. J Braz Chem Soc 26:19942002
Asveld L, RV
Est, D Stemerding (2011). Getting to the Core of the Bio-economy. A Perspective
on the Sustainable Promise of Biomass, p:194. The Hague: Rathenau
Institute, Amsterdam, The Netherlands
Ayed F, RAB Abdallah, O Boussadia, H Jabnoun-Khiareddine,
M Daami-Remadi (2022).
Potential of composted agricultural wastes to control stem rot and to promote
growth in tomato. Pol J Environ Stud 31:112
Azbar N, A
Bayram, A Filibeli, A Muezzinoglu, F Sengul, A Ozer (2004). A review of waste
management options in olive oil production. Crit Rev Environ Sci Technol
34:209247
Baccouri O, A
Bendini, L Cerretani, M Guerfel, B Baccouri, G Lercker, M Zarrouk, DD Milled
(2008). Comparative study on volatile
compounds from Tunisian and Sicilian monovarietal virgin olive oils. Food Chem 111:322328
Barbera A, C
Maucieri, V Cavallaro, A Ioppolo, G Spagna (2013). Effects of spreading olive
mill wastewater on soil properties and crops, a review. Agric Water Manage
119:4353
Bateman ML, RK Day, I Rwomushana, S Subramanian, K
Wilson, D Babendreier, B Luke, S Edgington (2021). Updated assessment of
potential biopesticide options for managing fall armyworm (Spodoptera
frugiperda) in Africa. J Appl Entomol 145:384393
Berbel J, A Posadillo (2018). Review and
analysis of alternatives for the valorisation of agro-industrial olive oil
by-products. Sustain 10:237-245
Boz O, D Ogut,
K Kir, MN Dogan (2009). Olive processing waste as a method of weed control for
okra, faba bean and onion. Weed Technol 23:569573
Bueno L, G
Bosch-Rubia, R Sanchez-Montilla, P Monetta (2014). Use of compost from olive
oil by-products as soil amendment: Effect on physical and chemical properties
of loamy-sand soils. Acta Hortic 1057:417422
Buono DD, DS
Pullicino, P Proietti, L Nasini, G Gigliotti (2011). Utilization of olive husks
as plant growing substrates: Phytotoxicity and plant biochemical responses. Compost
Sci Utiliz 19:5260
Burger
J, F Mol, B Gerowitt (2008). The necessary extent of pesticide use - thoughts
about a key term in German pesticide policy. Crop Prot 27:343351
Campagna
C, C Guillemette, P Ayotte, JL Bailey (2009) Effects of an environmentally
relevant organochlorine mixture and a metabolized extract of this mixture on
porcine sperm parameters in vitro. J
Androl 30:317324
Carvalho FP
(2017). Pesticides, environment, and food safety. Pest Food Ener Secur 6:4860
Castellani F, A Vitali, N Bernardi, E Marone, F
Palazzo, L Grotta, G Martino (2017). Dietary supplementation with dried olive
pomace in dairy cows modifies the composition of fatty acids and the aromatic
profile in milk and related cheese. J Dairy Sci 100:86588669
Castro T, A
Cabezas, JDL Fuente, B Isabel, T Manso, V Jimeno (2016). Animal performance and
meat characteristics in steers reared in intensive conditions fed with different
vegetable oils. Animal 10:520530
Cayuela ML, PD Millner, SLF
Meyer, A Roiga (2008). Potential of olive mill waste and compost as biobased
pesticides against weeds, fungi, and nematodes. Sci Total Environ 399:1118
Cayuela ML, P Millner, J Slovin, A Roig (2007). Duckweed (Lemna gibba)
growth inhibition bioassay for evaluating the toxicity of olive mill wastes
before and during composting. Chemosphere 68:19851991
Chandler D, A Bailey,
GM Tatchell, G Davidson, J Greaves, WP Grant (2011). The development,
regulation and use of biopesticides for integrated pest management. Phil
Trans Roy Soc Bull 386:213
Chaves BW, GAF Valles, RB Scheibler, JS Junior,
JL Nornberg (2021). Milk yield of cows submitted to different levels of olive
pomace in the diet. Acta Scientiarum Anim Sci 43:1-9
Chiofalo V, L
Liotta, VL Presti, F Gresta, ARD Rosa, B Chiofalo (2020). Effect of dietary
olive cake supplementation on performance, carcass characteristics, and meat
quality of beef cattle. Animal 10:1176-1192
Chouchene A, M
Jeguirim, B Khiari, F Zagrouba, G Trouvι (2010). Thermal degradation of olive
solid waste: Influence of particle size and oxygen concentration. Res Conserv
Recycl 54:271277
Choudhary S, NR Yamini, KY Sushil, ML Kamboj, S Amit
(2018). A review: Pesticide residue: Cause of many animal health problems. J
Entomol Zool Stud 6:330333
Chowdhury
AKMB, CS Akratos, DV Vayenas, S Pavlou (2013). Olive mill waste composting: A
review. Intl Biodeter Biodegrad 85:108119
Christodoulou V, V Bampidis, C Israilides, P Robinson, A
Giouzelyiannis, A Vlyssides (2008). Nutritional value of fermented olive wastes
in growing lamb rations. Anim Feed Sci Technol 141:375383
Coelho L, M
Reis, C Guerrero, L Dionisio (2020). Use of organic composts to suppress bentgrass
diseases in Agrotis stolonifera. Biol Cont 141:1134
Cooperband L
(2002). The Art and Science of Composting: A Resource for Farmers and Compost
Producers. University of Wisconsin, Madison, Wisconsin, USA
Corato UD, L
Patruno, N Avella, G Lacolla, G Cucci (2019). Composts from green sources show
an increased suppressiveness to soil-borne plant pathogenic fungi: Relationship
between physicochemical properties, disease suppression, and the microbiome. Crop
Prot 24:104870
Corato UD, ID
Bari, E Viola, M Pugliese (2018). Assessing the main opportunities of
integrated biorefining from agro-bioenergy co/by-products and agro-industrial
residues into high-value added products associated to some emerging markets: A
review. Renew Sustain Ener Rev 88:326395
DAddabbo T, N Sasanelli, F Lamberti, P Greco, A Carella
(2003). Olive pomace and chicken manure amendments for control of Meloidogyne
incognita over two crop cycles. Nematropica 33:17
Dermeche S, M
Nadour, C Larroche, F Moulti-Mati, P Michaud (2013). Olive mill wastes: Biochemical
characterizations and valorization strategies. Proc Biochem 48:15321552
Deshmukh SS,
BM Prasanna, CM Kalleshwaraswamy, J Jaba, B Choudhary (2021). Fall armyworm Spodoptera
frugiperda (JE Smith). Ind J Entomol 82:349372
Diacono M, F
Montemurro (2019). Olive pomace compost in organic emmer crop: Yield, soil
properties, and heavy metals fate in plant and soil. J Soil Sci Plant Nutr
19:6370
Dimetry NZ (2012).
Prospects of botanical pesticides for the future in integrated pest management
programme (IPM) with special reference to neem uses in Egypt. Arch
Phytopathol Plant Prot 45:11381161
Drobek M, M Frac,
J Cybulska (2019). Plant biostimulants: Importance of the quality and yield of
horticultural crops and the improvement of plant tolerance to abiotic stress
a review. Agron 9:335352
Dunne G (2019). Transforming olive waste into
animal feed. Intl J Clin Nutr Diet 5:142145
Fayed AM, KM Youssef, HMAE Nasr (2001).
Nutritional performance of goat fed non-conventional diets based on olive pulp
in Sinai. Egypt J Nutr Feeds 1:8189
Gabriele A, L
Giuseppe, L Giuseppe, V Domenico, R Giancarlo (2011). Characterization of
composted olive mill wastes to predict potential plant disease suppressiveness.
Biol Cont 58:199207
Galanakis CM
(2017). Olive Mill Waste Recent Advances for Sustainable Management, p:284.
Academic Press, London
Ghabeish IH, FA Al-Zyoud, DS Hassawi (2021). RAPD
analysis and field screening of bread wheat and barley accessions for
resistance to cereal leafminer Syringopais temperatella. Jor J Biol
Sci 14:209310
Giusquiani
PL, M Pagliai, G Gigliotti, D Businelli, A Benetti (1995). Urban waste compost:
Effects on physical, chemical, and biochemical soil properties. J Environ
Qual 24:175182
Glover-Amengor M, FM Tetteh (2008). Effect of pesticide
application rate on yield of vegetables and soil microbial communities. West Afr J Appl Ecol 12:17
Gomez-Munoz B, DJ Hatch, R Bol, R Garcia-Ruiz (2012). The compost of olive
mill pomace: From a waste to a resource environmental benefits of its
application in olive oil groves. In: Sustainable Development-Authoritative and
Lead Edge Content for Environmental Management, pp:459484. InTech Open, London
Haddadin MS, SM
Abdulrahim (1999). Solid state fermentation of waste pomace from olive processing.
J Chem Technol Biotechnol 74:613618
Haddadin MS, J
Haddadin, OI Arabiyat, B Hattar (2009). Biological conversion of olive pomace
into compost by using Trichoderma harzianum and Phanerochaete
chrysosporium. Biores Technol 100:473478
Hong J, H Feng, F Wang, A Ranjan, J Chen, J Jiang, R Ghirlando, T SamXiao, C Wu, Y Bai (2014). The
catalytic subunit of the SWR1 remodeler is a histone chaperone for the
H2A.Z-H2B dimer. Mol Cell 53:498505
IOOC (2021). International Olive Oil Council Webpage,
World Olive Oil Fig. http://www.inter nationaloliveoil.org
Ippolito
A, M Kattwinkel, JJ Rasmussen, RB Schafer, R Fornaroli, M Liess (2015).
Modeling global distribution of agricultural insecticides in surface waters. Environ
Pollut 198:5460
Jayashree
M, S Singhi (2011). Changing trends and predictors of outcome in patients with
acute poisoning admitted to the intensive care. J Trop Pediatr
57:340346
Jerman T, BM
Vodopivec (2012). The fate of olive fruit phenols during commercial olive oil
processing: Traditional press versus continuous two- and three-phase centrifuge.
Food Sci Technol 49:267274
Kavdir Y, U Gozel,
N Sahiner (2019). Nematicidal effects of olive pomace and green walnut husk on
root-knot nematode Meloidogyne incognita on tomato. Allelopathy J
46:316
Khdair A, G
Abu-Rumman (2020). Sustainable environmental management and valorization
options for olive mill byproducts in the Middle East and North Africa (MENA)
Region. Processes 8:671692
Komilis DP,
IS Tziouvaras (2009). A statistical analysis to assess the maturity and stability
of six composts. Waste Manage 29:15041513
Liguori L, C
Pance, D Albanese, G Celano, M Zaccrdelli, MD Matteo (2015). Compost and
compost tea management of mini watermelon cultivations affect the chemical,
physical and sensory assessment of the fruits. Agric Sci 6:117125
Lin S, S Li, Z
Liu, L Zhang, H Wu, D Cheng, Z Zhang (2021). Using azadirachtin to transform Spodoptera
frugiperda from pest to natural enemy. Toxins 13:112
Mahadevakumar
S, V Yadav, GS Tejaswini, GR Janardhana (2016). Morphological and molecular
characterization of Sclerotium rolfsii associated with fruit rot of Cucurbita
maxima. Eur J Plant Pathol 145:215219
Mameri N, F
Aioueche, D Belhocine, H Grib, H Lounici, DL Piron (2000). Preparation of
activated carbon from olive mill solid residue. J Chem Technol Biotechnol
75:625631
Mamkagh A, E
Anderson (2018). Condensation rate enhancement of the inclined condenser n the
solar still connected with a solar water heater. Eng Technol J 10:492497
Mamkagh AM
(2009). Effect of tillage time and plastic mulch on growth and yield of okra (Abelmoschus
esculentus) grown under rain-fed conditions. Intl J Agric Biol 11:453457
Maniadakis K,
K Lasaridi, Y Manios, M Kyriacou, T Manios (2004). Integrated waste management
through producers and consumers education: Composting of vegetable crop
residues for reuse in cultivation. J Environ Sci Health 39:169183
Mariyono J (2008).
Farmers economic tolerance toward pest infestations: Impact of integrated pest
management training in Indonesia. Quart J Intl Agric 47:6173
Martin CCG, A
Ramsubhag (2015). Potential of compost for suppressing plant diseases. In:
Sustainable Crop Disease Management Using Natural Products, p:345. Ganesan
S, K Vadivel, J Jayaraman (Eds). CABI, Wallingford, UK
Mechri B, FB
Mariem, M Baham, SB Elhadj, M Hammami (2008). Change in soil properties and the
soil microbial community following land spreading of olive mill wastewater
affects olive trees key physiological parameters and the abundance of arbuscular
mycorrhizal fungi. Soil Biol Biochem 40:152161
Mekersi N, K
Kadi, S Casini, D Addad, KE Bazri, SE
Marref, S Lekmine, A Amari (2021). Effects of single and combined olive mill
wastewater and olive mill pomace on the growth, reproduction, and survival of
two earthworm species (Aporrectodea trapezoides, Eisenia fetida).
Appl Soil Ecol 168:104123
Michailides M,
G Christou, CS Akratos, AG Tekerlekopoulou, DV Vayenas (2011). Composting of
olive leaves and pomace from a three-phase olive mill plant. Intl Biodeter
Biodegrad 65:560564
Mili S (2006).
Olive oil marketing on non-traditional markets: Prospects and strategies. Mediterr
J Econ Agric Environ 5:2737
Mitra
A, C Chatterjee, FB Mandal (2011). Synthetic pesticides and their effect on
birds. Res J Environ Toxicol 5:8196
Muraro DS, DOAD Neto, RH Kanno, IS Kaiser, O Bernardi, C
Omoto (2021). Inheritance patterns, cross-resistance and synergism in Spodoptera
frugiperda (Lepidoptera: Noctuidae) resistant to emamectin benzoate. Pest
Manage Sci 77:50495057
Naharki K, S Regmi, N Shrestha (2020). A review on
invasion and management of fall armyworm Spodoptera Frugiperda in Nepal.
Rev Food Agric 1:611
Niassy S, MK Agbodzavu, E Kimathi, B Mutune, EM
Abdel-Rahman, D Salifu, G Hailu, YT Belayneh, E Felege, HEZ Tonnang, S Ekesi, S
Subramanian (2021). Bioecology of fall armyworm Spodoptera frugiperda (JE
Smith), its management and potential patterns of seasonal spread in Africa. PLoS
One 16:124
Ntougias S, K Papadopoulou, G Zervakis, N Kavroulakis, C Ehaliotis (2008).
Suppression of soil-borne pathogens of tomato by composts derived from
agro-industrial wastes abundant in Mediterranean regions. Biol Fertil Soil
44:10811090
Ofuoku AU, EO Egho, EC
Enujeke (2009). Integrated pest management adoption among farmers in Central
agroecological zone of Delta State, Nigeria. Afr J Agric Res 3:123130
Oguh CE, AD Musa, TG
Orum, RO Iyaji, A Musa (2019a). Risk assessment of heavy metals level in soil
and jute leaves (Corchorus olitorius) treated with azadirachtin neem
seed solution and organochlorine. Intl J Environ Agric Biotechnol
4:256266
Oguh
CE, CO Okpaka, CS Ubani, U Okekeaji, PS Joseph, EU Amadi (2019b). Natural pesticides
(biopesticides) and uses in pest management a critical review. 2019. Asian
J Biotechnol Genet Eng 2:118
Ogunnupebi TA,
AP Oluyori, AO Dada, OS Oladeji, AA Inyinbor, GO Egharevba (2020). Promising
natural products in crop protection and food preservation: Basis, advances, and
future prospects. Intl J Agron 2020:128
Oliveira COD,
AAP Roll, MFM Gonηalves, DCN Lopes, EG Xavier (2021). Olive pomace for the
feeding of commercial poultry: Effects on performance, meat and eggs quality,
haematological parameters, microbiota and immunity. World Poul Sci J 77:363376
Omer AM, MA
Mohamed (2012). Effect of olive pomace phenols on the soil fungi and alfalfa yield.
Res J Agric Biol Sci 8:5561
Ortega RM
(2006). Importance of functional foods in the Mediterranean diet. Publ
Health Nutr 9:11361140
Pages LA, HR
Miller, RD Kenney (1982). Methods of soil analysis. Chemical and Microbiological
Properties, 2nd edn. Wisconsin, Madison, Wisconsin, USA
Pal GK, B Kumar
(2013). Antifungal activity of some common weed extracts against wilt causing
fungi, Fusarium oxysporum. Curr Discov 2:6267
Parascanu M,
P Sanchez, G Soreanu, J Valverde, L Sanchez-Silva (2018). Environmental
assessment of olive pomace valorization through two different thermochemical
processes for energy production. J Clean Prod 186:771781
Paredes-Sanchez FA, G Rivera, V Bocanegra-Garcia, HY
Martinez-Padron, M Berrones-Morales, N Nino-Garcia, V Herrera-Mayorga (2021).
Advances in control strategies against Spodoptera frugiperda a review.
Molecules 26:119
Pattnaik
M, BK Pany, J Dena, AK Pal, G Sahu (2020). Effect of organochlorine pesticides
on living organisms and environment. Chem Sci Rev Lett 9:682686
Radwan MA, EK
El-Maadawy, SI Kassem, MM Abu-Elamayem (2009). Oil
cakes soil amendment effects on Meloidogyne incognita, root-knot
nematode infecting tomato. Arch Phytopathol Plant Prot 42:5864
Raipulis
J, M Maija, M Balode (2009). Toxicity and genotoxicity testing of roundup. Proc
Latv Acad Sci B 63:2932
Roig A, M
Cayuela, M Sanchez-Monedero (2006). An overview on olive mill wastes and their valorization
methods. Waste Manage 26:960969
Ryckeboer J,
J Mergaert, J Coosemans, K Deprins, J Swings (2003). Microbiological aspects of
bio-waste during composting in a monitored compost bin. J Appl Microbiol
94:127137
Sadeghi H, AT Ynsari, Z Ansari-Pirsarai (2009). Effects
of different olive cake by products on dry matter intake, nutrient
digestibility and performance of Zel sheep. Intl J Agric Biol 11:3943
Saleh A, M Alzawqari (2021). Effects of replacing yellow
corn with olive cake meal on growth performance, plasma lipid profile, and
muscle fatty acid content in broilers. Animal 11:22402249
Salma M, CK Jogen
(2011). A review on the use of biopesticides in insect pest management. Intl
J Sci Adv Technol 1:169178
Samiee A, A Rezvanfar, E Faham (2009). Factors
influencing the adoption of integrated pest management by wheat growers in
Varamin County, Iran. Afr J Agric Res 4:491497
Sasanelli N, T
D'Addabbo, L Mancini (2011). Suppressive effect of composted olive mill wastes
soil amendments on the root-knot nematode Meloidogyne incognita. Acta Hortic 914:229231
Sciubba F, L
Chronopoulou, D Pizzichini, V Lionetti, C Fontana, R Aromolo, S Socciarelli, L
Gambelli, B Bartolacci, E Finotti, A Benedetti, A Miccheli, U Neri, C Palocci,
D Bellincampi (2020). Olive mill wastes: A source of bioactive molecules for
plant growth and protection against pathogens. Biology 9:450469
Scotti R, C
Pane, R Spaccini, AM Palese, A Piccolo, G Celano, M Zaccardelli (2016). Onfarm
compost: A useful tool to improve soil quality under intensive farming systems.
Appl Soil Ecol 107:1323
Selim K, W
Badawy, I Smetanska (2020). Utilization of olive pomace as a source of
bioactive compounds in quality improvement of toast bread. Egypt J Food Sci
48:2740
Sellami F, R
Jarboui, S Hachicha, K Medhioub, E Ammar (2008). Co-composting of oil exhausted
olive-cake, poultry manure, and industrial residues of agro-food activity for
soil amendment. Biores Technol 99:11771188
Senesi N
(1989). Composted materials as organic fertilizers. Sci Total Environ
81:521542
Shdiefat S, S Ayoub, K Jamjoum (2009).
Effect of irrigation with reclaimed wastewater on soil properties and olive oil
quality. Jor J Agric Sci 5:128141
Shojaei SH, SJ Hosseini, M Mirdamadi,
HR Zamanizadeh (2013). Investigating barriers to adoption of integrated pest
management technologies in Iran. Ann Biol Res 4:3942
Siddique
A, M Liess, N Shahid, JM Becker (2020). Insecticides in agricultural streams
exert pressure for adaptation but impair performance in Gammarus pulex
at regulatory acceptable concentrations. Sci Total Environ 722:137750
Singh
A, SK Nagb, S Singha (2014). Persistent organochlorine pesticide residue in
tissues and blood of goat. J Appl Anim Res 43:366371
Sun S, F Sun,
D Denf, X Zhu, C Duan, Z Zhu (2020). First report of southern blight of mung
bean caused by Sclerotium rolfsii in China. Crop Prot 130:105055
Tawarah KM, RA Rababah (2013). Characterization of some Jordanian crude
and exhausted olive pomace samples. Green Sustain Chem 3:146162
Terramoccia S,
S Bartocci, A Taticchi, S Giovanni, M Pauselli, E Mourvaki, S Urbani, M Servili
(2013). Use of dried stoned olive pomace in the feeding of lactating buffaloes:
Effect on the quantity and quality of the
milk produced. Asian-Aust J Anim Sci 26:971980
Tijjani A, K Bashir,
I Mohammed, A Muhammad, A Gambo, H Musa (2016). Biopesticides for pests
control: A review. J Biopest Agric 3:613
Tubeileh AM,
GT Stephenson (2020). Soil amendment by composted plant wastes reduces the Verticillium
dahliae abundance and changes soil chemical properties in a bell pepper
cropping system. Curr Plant Biol 22:100148
Tzamaloukas O,
MC Neofytou, PE Simitzis (2021). Application of olive by-products in livestock
with emphasis on small ruminants: Implications on rumen function, growth
performance, milk and meat quality. Anim 11:531544
Uwagboe EO, LA Akinbile,
OO Oduwole (2012). Socio-economic factors and integrated pest management
utilization among cocoa farmers in Edo State. Acad J Plant Sci 5:711
Vargas-Bello-Pιrez E, C Geldsetzer-Mendoza, MS
Morales, P Toro-Mujica, MA Fellenberg, RA Ibanez, PC Garnsworthy (2018). Effect
of olive oil in dairy cow diets on the fatty acid profile and sensory
characteristics of cheese. Intl Dairy J 85:815
Varo-Suarez A, MC
Raya-Ortegaa, C Agusti-Brisacha, C Garcıa-Ortiz-Civantos, A
Fernandez-Hernandez, A Mulero-Aparicioa, A Traperoa (2017). Evaluation of
organic amendments from agro-industry waste for the control of verticillium
wilt of olive. Plant Pathol 67:860870
Youssef KM, AM
Fayed, HS Khamis (2001). Productive and reproductive performance of ewes and does
fed non-conventional diets based on olive pulp in Sinai. Egyp J Nutr Feeds
4:591